10 Tips For Deciding Between Two Job Offers

Search local, regional and global jobs and candidates.

Receiving two excellent job offers after applying, interviewing, and finding a new job may be both thrilling and terrifying. Multiple job offers on the table provide the comfort of employment stability and confirm your credentials, but they also force you to make an important life choice.
Think carefully about how each position’s potential effects on your personal and professional aspirations may affect your decision between two tempting employment offers. This article offers comprehensive instructions for comparing the advantages of two occupations and choosing the one that best suits you.



The right time to pick between two jobs 

When job seekers submit several applications, they increase their chances of receiving two job offers. Due to their specific skills and credentials, individuals with a history of success in their industry can be hired by two organizations. Set a quick deadline for choosing any situation you may need to select between two employment offers. Doing it right now will help you advance your career and prevent one of the companies from hiring someone else. 

The way to choose a job between two options

Your capacity to assess a situation and choose the best course of action develops when you choose between two job offers. This ability will help you grow your career in any sector. The following are the main procedures for selecting between two jobs: 

  1. Assemble all relevant data. 
  2. Being truthful. 
  3. Make a chart of comparisons. 
  4. Choose what is important. 
  5. Discover the culture of the business. 
  6. Review your colleagues. 
  7. Discuss compensation. 
  8. Think about your short-term and long-term objectives. 
  9. Think of each position as your own. 
  10. Engage in dialogue with both employers.



1. Assemble all relevant data

It would help you thoroughly comprehend each employer’s offers to decide which position you wish to accept. Look through the material in your offer letters on pay and benefits, and ask the recruiting managers if any information needs to be clarified or added. Ask about eligibility requirements and probationary terms after investigating the benefits’ nature. Make a note of the various components of each job offer and have it in writing, including the following: 

  • Start date and probation period
  • Salary
  • Stock options
  • Profit-sharing
  • Signing bonus
  • Performance bonuses
  • Retirement accounts
  • Frequency of raises
  • Hours of work per week
  • Overtime compensation
  • Vacation time
  • Company holidays
  • Personal days
  • Sick days
  • Family leave
  • Health insurance
  • Life insurance
  • Relocation funds
  • Travel stipends
  • Tuition reimbursement
  • Discounts

2. Being truthful

Maintain open lines of communication and let employers know how you make decisions. Employers know that job hopeful may not accept an offer of employment right away, but mentioning that you need a few days to think it over displays professionalism and typical politeness. After you get a job offer, acknowledge it, thank the employer, and mention that you are considering several other opportunities. If a corporation demands a prompt response, you should proceed with caution since this can mean they don’t value your time or your requirements as an employee. 

3. Make a chart of comparisons

To illustrate how the positions and employers compare to one another, make a chart. You can see trends for which perk fits the bill more comprehensively by putting each benefit side by side. If you are still torn between comparable job offers, list the advantages and disadvantages of each one in writing. Include any information that influences your everyday experience or work satisfaction in addition to each of the previously specified financial offer components, such as: 

  • Job description
  • General work environment
  • Office amenities
  • Office ergonomics
  • Commute
  • Location
  • Paths for advancement
  • Size of Company
  • Company reputation
  • Values and mission statement
  • Networking opportunities

4. Choose what is important

Consider the qualities of a job you value most, and give those considerations greater weight when choosing between options. Consider the significance of each component of the job offer and how it will affect your life and career. Ask yourself why each element is significant. Concentrate on the advantages that are most important to you and pertinent to your needs, wants, and values. 

For instance, a firm could provide a work-from-home option as one of its perks, but if you prefer to engage with colleagues in an office setting, this perk is irrelevant. Someone under 25 covered by their parent’s plan will not find excellent health coverage as significant, but an uninsured person can take full use of this benefit. 

5. Discover the culture of the business

Consider the culture of each organization in addition to the perks it offers. Learning about corporate culture may be accomplished by investigating employee experiences, such as those found in online company evaluations. If you have been offered a position in a big organization where departmental cultures differ, you should also inquire about those cultures from your prospective colleagues and the hiring manager. Consider carefully which of the two work environments you would like since company culture significantly influences your satisfaction and productivity.



6. Review your colleagues

Your productivity at work and how much you love your job are significantly influenced by the individuals you work with. Examine your encounters with the recruiting managers at each business and try to picture how you would respond if you were working under their leadership. If you come across any additional persons you would want to collaborate with, consider how you would do so. An excellent technique to choose between job offers with comparable perks and pay is to assess the degree of cooperation and assistance in each organization.

7. Discuss compensation

Consider negotiating compensation if you prefer one job over another but the other offers a superior benefits package. Consider what advantages or accommodations you would need to accept each offer, and speak with the recruiting manager about any terms that are non-negotiable for you. A suitable applicant will often get extra advantages from employers. This is particularly true if they know another business is vying for your expertise.

8. Think about your short-term and long-term objectives

Consider your short- and long-term objectives, such as the career path you want in your field, pay needs, and learning possibilities while choosing between two positions. Think about how each work might further your desired career while being realistic about your immediate requirements. Consider which function can sustain your job for many years and promote an excellent work-life balance. 

9. Think of each position as your own

Intuition is an excellent tool to use while deciding between two jobs. Consider each job as if you were in it, and consider the typical day for each company. Think about the job that makes you the most enthusiastic and why the other job appears less fascinating. To determine if you would do well in each position, rely on your impressions of the organization, your colleagues, and the role. 

10. Engage in dialogue with both employers

Once you’ve decided, let both employers know as soon as possible. This demonstrates respect and professionalism, which may open doors for future employment. Before respectfully alerting the other company that you took another career, be sure to wait until your first choice has written down their acknowledgment of your acceptance of their offer. Be courteous while being accepted or rejected, and thank the recruiting managers for their time.



With more than 12 years of experience in career counseling, recruitment, and leadership positions to assist others in finding their ideal careers, Jennifer Herrity is a seasoned career services expert. Through one-on-one career counseling, webinars, seminars, essays, and career guidance videos on Indeed’s YouTube channel, she assists individuals in navigating the job search process. 

This video discusses things to think about before moving on to the next phase of your career, from wage expectations to workplace culture.




iGlobalTalent takes a data-driven approach to connect opportunities with exceptional global talent. Talk to us today about how we can help you identify, engage and attract people to your company, university, city or country. Contact us at talent@iglobaltalent.com